Spectrum Software
spacer
Industrial Strength Simulation
select:

divider

 

News:

Spectrum Software has released Micro-Cap 11, the eleventh generation of our SPICE circuit simulator.

For users of previous Micro-Cap versions, check out the new features available in the latest version. For those of you who are new to Micro-Cap, take our features tour to see what Micro-Cap has to offer.

 

divider

 

Modeling Skin Effect in an AC Analysis

 

The lossy transmission line component can now use the F and S variables directly in the model statement of the device. Any of the four impedance parameters (R, L, C, and G) can use these variables in order to define a frequency dependent expression for an AC analysis simulation. This capability provides a simple method to model transmission line characteristics such as skin effect.

Skin effect is the phenomenon where the apparent resistance of a wire increases as the frequency increases. At DC, the charge carriers have an even distribution throughout the area of the wire. However, as the frequency increases, the magnetic field near the center of the wire increases the local reactance. The charge carriers subsequently move towards the edge of the wire, decreasing the effective area and increasing the apparent resistance.

The area through which the charge carriers flow is referred to as the skin depth. The skin depth is frequency dependent, and we will use it to calculate the AC resistance by implementing its transfer function in the R parameter of the lossy transmission line model. The first step is to compute the transfer function for the AC resistance. The AC and DC resistances are related through the effective area of the wire as follows. Refer to the figure below for a graphical representation of the variables used.

AC resistance / DC resistance = DC area / AC area

AC resistance = (DC area / AC area) * DC resistance

DC area = PI * R * R

AC area = (PI * R * R) - (PI * r * r)

r = R - e

e = (3.16e3 / (2 * PI)) * Sqrt(res / (f * km))

AC resistance = ((PI * R * R) / (PI * R * R - PI * (R - e)*(R - e))) * DC resistance

where e is the skin depth, res is the resistivity, f is the frequency, and km is the relative permeability. The AC resistance has now been reduced to depending on only the frequency variable and constants. The skin depth equation presented here is only valid for higher frequency analysis, so we will analyze it at 50kHz and higher.

a) DC Representation of a Wire  b) AC Representation of a Wire

The basic lossy transmission line model using the skin effect equation is as follows where Rad is the radius of the line, Res is the resistivity, km is the relative permeability, and DCRes is the DC resistance.

.MODEL TLSkin TRN (C=2n L=1.12n LEN=1
+ R={((PI*Rad**2)/((PI*Rad**2)-PI*(Rad-503.3*(sqrt(Res/(km*F))))**2))*DCRes})

As an example, a pair of 1 meter sections of AWG No. 22 wire will be simulated. Two transmission line models will be created, one line using copper material characteristics and the other line using aluminum material characteristics. The resulting models are as follows:

* Copper Line
.MODEL TLCopper TRN (C=2n L=1.12n LEN=1
+ R={((PI*.322m**2)/((PI*.322m**2)-PI*(.322m-503.3*(sqrt(1.75e-8/(1*F))))**2))*.0537})

* Aluminum Line
.MODEL TLAlum TRN (C=2n L=1.12n LEN=1
+ R={((PI*.322m**2)/((PI*.322m**2)-PI*(.322m-503.3*(sqrt(2.83e-8/(1*F))))**2))*.0868})

The transmission lines have been setup in the configuration shown below with source and load resistances of 50 ohms.

Skin effect example circuit

The resulting AC analysis is shown below. The top plot displays the output voltage of each tranmission line in decibels. As can be seen, at higher frequencies the aluminum transmission line produces a higher AC resistance and a greater loss.

The bottom plot displays the actual resistance value being used for each transmission line in the simulation. The T1.R expression plots the R parameter for the T1 component which is the aluminum line. The T2.R does the same for the copper line.

Skin effect AC analysis

The use of the F and S parameters in the transmission line is only meaningful in an AC analysis. For any other analysis, these variables are set to a value of 0. For the skin effect model, that would produce a divide by 0 problem. In this case, the transmission line models can be set through the following If statement.

.if analysis==_AC
.MODEL TLCopper TRN (C=2n L=1.12n LEN=1
+ R={((PI*.322m**2)/((PI*.322m**2)-PI*(.322m-503.3*(sqrt(1.75e-8/(1*F))))**2))*.0537})
.MODEL TLAlum TRN (C=2n L=1.12n LEN=1
+ R={((PI*.322m**2)/((PI*.322m**2)-PI*(.322m-503.3*(sqrt(2.83e-8/(1*F))))**2))*.0868})
.else
.MODEL TLCopper TRN (C=2n L=1.12n LEN=1
+ R={((PI*.322m**2)/((PI*.322m**2)-PI*(.322m-503.3*(sqrt(1.75e-8/(1*Freq))))**2))*.0537})
.MODEL TLAlum TRN (C=2n L=1.12n LEN=1
+ R={((PI*.322m**2)/((PI*.322m**2)-PI*(.322m-503.3*(sqrt(2.83e-8/(1*Freq))))**2))*.0868})
.endif

If the analysis type is AC, then the first pair of models is used. For any other analysis, the second pair of models is used. The only difference between the two sets is that in the second pair the F variable has been replaced with a variable called Freq. The Freq variable would need to be set through a define statement such as:

.define Freq 1Meg

In this case, the resistance value of the transmission lines when operating at 1MHz would be used in the other analyses.

 
Download Spring 2011 Circuit Files
Return to the main Newsletter page